Methods & practice / Pros & cons
GTD pros and cons: is Getting Things Done right for you?
By Sigmalist · A practical assessment
What is GTD?
Getting Things Done (GTD) is David Allen’s method for keeping track of work and life. Its five steps are capture, clarify, organize, reflect, and engage. In plain language: write things down, decide what needs doing, put reminders where you will see them, review your lists, and do the work. A ‘next action’ is a concrete step you can take, such as emailing someone to arrange a meeting.
Start with the source: David Allen Company: What is GTD?.
The pros of GTD
01You have less to remember
Requests can get lost between messages, notes, and memory. Keeping them in places you check gives you a way to find them again. It also helps you see how much you have already agreed to do.
02Vague tasks become clear next steps
‘Fix the website’ leaves you with a decision every time you read it. ‘Write three headline options’ gives you somewhere to start. When not knowing what to do is the problem, this can help.
03You get a chance to rethink your plans
Reviewing your lists helps you spot tasks you need to check on and work that no longer matters. You can drop a task or change a commitment instead of carrying it around forever.
The cons of GTD
Keeping track of a task does not guarantee you will start it. These complaints describe ways GTD can fall short in everyday use.
01Knowing the next step does not make you want to take it
A task can be clear and still feel uncomfortable. Reading a contractor’s reply, for example, may mean facing a mistake or a disagreement. Writing down the next action does not remove the fear of what comes after it.
02The same task can stay on your list for weeks
You see a task, skip it, and find it harder to face the next time. Important projects can stall even when their next steps are clear. A review shows you what has not moved, but you can still leave it planning to do the work ‘later’.
03Easy tasks can keep winning
Quick, predictable jobs can feel more appealing than difficult creative work, even with clear tasks and regular reviews. You can finish plenty of small jobs while the work that matters most stays untouched. A tidy list does not stop that pattern on its own.
04Having a reminder can make postponing feel okay
Knowing a task is safely stored for later can make it easier to leave alone. ‘I will not forget this’ can quietly become ‘I do not need to start this.’ A reminder protects you from forgetting; it does not ensure you act.
05You can put off the weekly review, too
The routine meant to keep your lists useful can become another task you avoid. A long backlog or the pressure to review everything thoroughly can make it hard to begin. GTD needs regular attention, including on days when you do not feel like giving it any.
What it looks like in practice
Imagine your list says ‘Email the client about the late payment.’ You know who to contact and what to ask. But you expect an awkward reply, so you answer easier emails first. At your next review, the task is still there, and every day it waits makes the conversation harder and the delay more noticeable to your client. GTD has helped you remember it and define the next step. You still need a way to face the part you are avoiding.
Who is it a good fit for?
GTD may help if you forget to check on tasks, juggle several projects, or often do not know where to begin. If you already know what to do but keep putting it off, organizing your list may only solve part of the problem. Pay attention to whether the work starts moving, not just whether your lists look better. Count the tasks you worked on, not only the ones you finished.
Try a small experiment first
Pick one task you have been putting off. Write a clear next step and try it. If that helps you start, the task may have been too vague. If you still avoid it, ask what feels difficult: the effort, the possible reply, or the fear of doing it badly? Try a smaller first attempt or ask someone for help. Check whether you actually started, rather than only rewriting the task.
Common questions
Does GTD help with procrastination?
It can. Making a vague task smaller and clearer can help you start. But when you already understand the task and still avoid it, a clearer list may not be enough.
Why do I keep skipping the same next action?
The step may still be too large, or something about it may feel unpleasant. It may also no longer matter enough to keep. Review the task honestly: change how you start, get help, make time for it, or decide to drop it. Keeping it on the list is not the same as moving it forward.
Does GTD require only one next action per project?
No. A project can have several next actions when they can be done independently. Having only one is not a rule of the method.
Sigmalist is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the creators of the methods discussed here. The tradeoffs here are editorial judgments, not promises of particular results.